Fake Reviews are Bad for Business— Even Yours. Here’s Why!

The growth of fake reviews starts with online review trends. According to the Brightlocal Local Consumer Review Survey, 82% of all consumers check the reviews before trusting a local business in 2020.

This means that online reviews—the views of strangers on the internet—are just as reliable for consumers as personal recommendations from friends and family (perhaps even more).

Recognizing the strength consumer reviews have to fuel online visibility and sales, it is hardly surprising that there is a thriving industry of fake ones.

Unfortunately, many businesses seem to have succumbed to the unethical technique of soliciting false reviews.

This form of trickery has become so ubiquitous in today’s congested cyberspace that business review sites like Amazon, Yelp, Facebook and Google, and even the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), have put protocols in place to cut off the influx of questionable reviews.

What is a Fake Review Anyway?

Before we get ahead of ourselves, let’s start by clarifying what qualifies as a “fake” review.

Fake reviews are explicitly designed to deceive the buyer’s thought processes, giving them a misleading impression on the point of purchasing. They are often generated by bots or “review farms” that profit by hiring people to write bogus reviews. This is precisely the opposite of an actual consumer’s honest and impartial opinion of a product, service, or business.

Companies typically invest in fake positive reviews to inspire consumer confidence and loyalty. This may occur when launching a new business, program or product that has no reviews yet. Or, it may be a tactic by a poorly rated business to appear better than its customers have rated it. Some companies also source negative reviews to tarnish their competitors’ online reputation.

There’s no way of telling how what percentage of reviews today are fake. But I sometimes wonder if the problem isn’t extremely widespread since I rarely see any rated business or product today with less than 4 stars.

How do Fake Reviews Work?

It is not hard for you to get fake reviews. Even if you are a new company that has never done any work, you can purchase hundreds of stellar reviews in a matter of days.

All you need to do is go online and type in the keyword “Buy Reviews.”

You will find hundreds of service providers offering “5-star review services,” promising “100% real people or real users.”

You can also get fake reviews via private Facebook groups, or the “Wild West” of the Internet, as we like to call it.

False reviews are cheap, too–running you anywhere between $5 and $10. Once you complete your service order, the service provider will post fake reviews on your business pages, local listings, and review website profiles.

Are Dishonest Reviews Worth it?

Fake reviews are a disservice to both the business resorting to them and the consumers who buy into them. Having said that, fake reviews do work—they would not be around if there were nothing to be gained from them.

But while some doctored reviews work, they only work temporarily. Once a business has set high hopes for its consumers through this dubious tactic, they have to deliver!

A glowing review would make the consumer expect a certain quality of service from the company. And if the company fails to deliver on those over-inflated expectations, they will generate many [real] negative reviews.

Also, keep in mind that business review sites deem many reviews posted in quick succession a red flag. If caught, you might end up losing your listing or, worse, get slapped with hefty penalties. The fallout of being flagged for fake reviews is really not worth what they offer.

Lastly, no matter what those “5-star review services claim,” your target customers can often tell if a review posted on your profile is fake. Today’s consumers are smart and savvy, and it is easy for them to discern that a generic, overly positive review just does not feel authentic.

How Customers Can Spot a False Review

Buyers are pretty good at spotting fake reviews. But what tends to sway their judgment as to whether a review is real or paid? Let’s explore the three most common “tells” of a fake review.

Fake Reviews Solicitation by spammer

Example of a spammed email offering to provide fake reviews. We received several identical emails from different addresses within a 3-day period.

1. Not Real People

One of the easiest ways to tell a fake review is by identifying the characteristics of the reviewer.

As you might expect, the “100% real people or real users” fake review service providers claim to use is not true. Fake reviews usually come from new and unverified accounts with few details and little or no history of other reviews.

These accounts either do not have a display image, or they have one pulled from Getty Images or Shutterstock. It is not rare to encounter a fake reviewer with a generic name using a celebrity picture as their display image to rave about a brand or their product/service online.

2. Generic One-Sided Praise and Broken English

You cannot possibly expect a fake review service provider to make a serious effort on posting reviews that sound genuine, can you?

Well, that is the reason why fake reviewers end up posting relatively short reviews with fewer subjective and anecdotal details. They all have a similar headline (such as “Amazing product!”) as well as the same cookie-cutter descriptions that highlight the attributes and features of the product/service.

Because many fake reviews are outsourced to content farms in foreign countries, they are also poorly constructed and often have typos and grammatical errors.

3. Spike in Reviews during a very Short Time Frame 

Fake reviewers typically post hundreds of positive reviews over a very short period of time. Let’s just say that if your business starts to get a sudden influx of excellent online feedback, your consumers would know it is a targeted campaign to add new fake reviews.

The best thing you can do to build your online reputation is to actually BE worthy of good reviews. But this requires a commitment to high quality and good service. It also involves learning to listen to customers—especially when they aren’t happy. As a marketing consultant, I have learned that customer complaints are one of the best ways to improve your business because your customer is (literally) telling you how to improve.

If you put in some effort and do real, good work, positive authentic reviews will follow.